Print

Category: All > State Issues

Hawaii's Hard Health Care Lesson

October 27, 2008
by Grace-Marie Turner

Published in The New York Post October 27, 2008

Hawaii just had a vivid les son in health-care economics, learning that if you offer people insurance for free - surprise, surprise - they'll quickly drop other coverage to enroll.

As a result, Hawaii is ending the only state universal child health-care program in the country after just seven months.

The program, called the Keiki (Child) Care Plan, was designed to provide coverage to children whose parents can't afford private insurance but who make too much to qualify for other public programs (such as Medicaid and Hawaii's State Children's Health Insurance Program). Keiki Care was free for these gap kids, except for a $7 office-visit fee.

But then state officials found that families were dropping private coverage to enroll their children in the plan. "People who were already able to afford health care began to stop paying for it so they could get it for free," said Dr. Kenny Fink of Hawaii's Department of Human Services.

In fact, 85 percent of the children in Keiki Care previously had been covered under a private, nonprofit plan that costs $55 a month.

When Gov. Linda Lingle saw the data, she pulled the plug on funding. With Hawaii facing budget shortfalls, she realized it was unwise to spend public money to replace private coverage that children already had.

Yet Lingle is facing a political firestorm in the state from critics who say that she's denying children health insurance - notwithstanding the fact that children in Hawaiian families earning up to $73,000 a year are eligible for Medicaid.

All this is a lesson for political leaders in Washington who are drafting plans now to expand SCHIP to children in families earning up to $82,000 a year or more. That expansion would wind up doing what Keiki Care did: mainly crowd out the private coverage that millions of middle-income kids already have.

During last year's Washington debate over expanding SCHIP, many politicians took a principled stand against expansion of the program into these middle-income families. They supported President Bush's veto because they feared that expanding coverage to children in higher-income families would largely just crowd out existing private insurance.

Plus, two-thirds of kids who lack health insurance are already eligible for government help through either SCHIP or Medicaid. The opponents of expansion said Congress' first priority should be to make sure these poorer, uninsured children are taken care of.

States have struggled to get these children enrolled. If there is a stampede to cover higher-income kids, the poorer kids will likely continue to get left behind.

The Hawaiian debacle should also be a caution to Barack Obama, who wants to mandate that all children have health insurance. This would plainly not only require penalties for those who didn't comply but also new programs to help parents get their children covered. The risk of crowd-out will be great.

MIT economist Jonathan Gruber says his studies "clearly show that crowd-out is significant" - on the order of 60 percent. In other words, SCHIP coverage replaces private health insurance 60 percent of the time, and the rate will be greater if we extend eligibility to higher-income families.

Universal coverage in any form is an increasingly elusive goal. Several states (including California, Pennsylvania, Illinois and Wisconsin) have attempted major efforts to advance toward health coverage for all citizens. All have had to turn back because the costs were prohibitive.

Massachusetts enacted a universal-coverage law in 2006 - but state officials no longer claim that achieving that goal is even possible. The law's backers had insisted that universal coverage was imperative to get costs under control - yet the state faces serious budget shortfalls even after imposing new fees and taxes and getting an extra $21 billion from the federal government to try to balance the program's books.

Health reform is a tricky business; any change can bring unintended consequences - especially if lawmakers don't get the incentives right.

That's why Hawaii had to say, "Aloha," to its Keiki Care program twice in just seven months.

Grace-Marie Turner is president of the Galen Institute, a research nonprofit focusing on free-market health reform.


Comments

anonymous at 01/06/2009 03:28:30

<A href="http://www.toppowerlevel.net">wow power leveling</A>

[url=http://www.toppowerlevel.net]wow power leveling[/url]

Wow power leveling

 

anonymous at 01/01/2009 22:00:29

At least buy wow gold for now.then
cheapest wow goldwas one whom world of

craft gold cheap
Mannoroth couldworld of warcraft gold cheap

especially not touch.buy cheap wow gold With the death of the queen?s

advisor, Lordbuy world of warcraft gold
Xavius, the WOW FAQcaptain had become

wow gold
her liaison. Whenever the glorious Azshara opted

WOW US
not to gift those buy wow goldworking in the
chamber with wow gold news her magnificent presence,
wow gold about the guard captain took her place.
my site is :http://www.game4power.com.



Life is hard. game news We should not give up hope. By the time we

have given wow support up, we are finished.

Chances are always wow gold news there. We have to
wow power leveling grab every single opportunity to help..., to
world of warcraft love and to serve. To live our

life wow tips happier, full of joy, we have
cheap wow gold to set our goal and even dream big. If we

choose the shortest path in life, we will never learn. To be or not to be, we have to be somebody. The fastest way to

gain love is to love buy wow goldothers first!Do

not hide your talent, wow gold FAQ your knowledge and your beautiful heart.

Go for your dream and live for it.[http://www.wowgoldone.com]

anonymous at 12/28/2008 01:27:58
Best china wholesale service, quick wholesale delivery, nice wholesale products, is there anything more you can expect on this platform? This net will build up a link between you and you supplier so that to be sure you would have a satisfied wholesale clothingwholesale apparel trading. The account managers will take care of all your wholesale products questions, inquires and help you manage your account. We provid popular wholesale products such as wholesale watch and wholesale electronics. Different from other platforms, we also provide consumer electronics products, for example car electronics and digital camera. Meanwhile, we offer the best bluetooth phones and GPS Cellphone . Well begun is the half done. Please choose our platform to shorten your way to the successwholesale shoes,wholesale handbagsand wholesale toysbr
we offer chloe betty handbag,hermes handbags,gucci handbags,,balenciaga handbags,mulberry handbag,roxanne bag,hermes kelly bags,chloe betty bags ,miumiu bags,d&g handbags,fendi spy bag,chloe ascot handbag,hermes birkin,prada handbag,jimmy choo,leather wallets hermes
we a supplier of those products.if you have any interest.contact ours Chinese antique furniture supplier and we can supplycar wash systems. car wash systems .car wash equipment. car wash equipment. automatic car wash .automatic car wash .car washing machine. car washing machine. car wash. car wash

h1楼梯有机玻璃电焊机硬度计测厚仪毛刷厂 毛刷毛刷北京汽车租赁防静电地板 白癜风 白癜风治疗货架 货架厂 网络地板 白癜风遮盖白癜风资讯白癜风资讯白癜风治疗有机玻璃加工数控切割机数控火焰切割机数控等离子切割机焊机健身器材 桶装水送水公司h1

工业毛刷 尖锐湿疣 尖锐湿疣治疗 生殖器疱疹 生殖器疱疹治疗
毛刷厂 帕金森清洗毛刷轻松过关名师课堂
粘钢胶树脂灌缝胶建筑结构胶植筋胶 结构胶灌浆料 灌浆
XYLITOLSODIUM SULPHATECAUSTIC SODA FLAKESMANGANESE SULFATESODIUM FORMATEMAGNESIUM SULFATEOXALIC ACIDFORMIC ACIDXYLITOLSODIUM SULPHATECAUSTIC SODA FLAKESMANGANESE SULFATESODIUM FORMATEMAGNESIUM SULFATEOXALIC ACIDFORMIC ACID
Chinese antique furniture supplier and we can supplycar wash systems. car wash systems .car wash equipment. car wash equipment. automatic car wash .automatic car wash .car washing machine. car washing machine. car wash. car wash if u need ,contact me
会计专业资格会计专业资格考试会计从业资格证书会计专业技术资格会计从业资格证初级职称初级会计资格初级会计职称会计报名中级会计资格中级会计职称初级会计职称考试中级会计职称考试09年中级会计职称考试轻松过关名师课堂闫华红田明王燕会计答疑会计试题会计职称模拟试卷会计职称考前串讲会计职称历年试题会计资讯会计职称考试报名会计职称称准考证会计名师会计职称培训会计从业资格试题09年会计从业资格考试2009年会计报名2009年会计职称考试规律总结职称考试应试技巧会计职称考试答案会计职称考试试题会计职称考试时间中级职称初级职称培训初级职称报名中级职称报名中级职称培训职称考试初级会计中级会计初级会计初级中级

会计考试报名会计职称考试报名会计职称报名时间会计中级职称报名注会成绩查询注会考试成绩查询会计考试复习资料会计考试教材会计考试辅导视频会计考试历年试题会计考试真题会计考试答疑会计辅导名师最好的会计网校会计辅导权威网校最好的会计网会计远程教育权威会计网校会计人网上家园注册会计师教材会计论坛注册会计师会计在线学习北京会计培训注税考试报名注税考试辅导教材注税考试辅导课程高会考试报名高会考试辅导教材高会考试辅导课程高级会计师会计考试论坛中级财务管理注会经济法中级经济法经济法基础初级会计实务公司战略与风险管理注会税法经济法基础中级会计实务注会政策改革注会会计注会财务成本管理注会审计会计中级报名指南注会会计
anonymous at 12/23/2008 02:52:07
Good~!i like it <a href="http://www.vcsale.com/">buy wow gold</a><br /> yes i miss you <a href="http://www.vcsale.com/">cheap wow gold</a><br /> hello~, i want to make friend with you ><a href="http://www.vcsale.com/">wow gold</a><br />
James at 11/22/2008 13:26:43
Hard to believe there were no comments on this article since half of America is dead-set on providing "uniersal" health care.

Add Comment